Former Negeri Sembilan Exco Members Withdraw Suit on Constitutional Crisis
SEREMBAN, Nov 18 — The High Court here was informed today that 10 former Negeri Sembilan state executive council (Exco) members have withdrawn their originating summons against the State Secretary and two other parties over the constitutional crisis in the state, without liberty to file afresh.High Court Judge Roz Mawar Rozain allowed the withdrawal after being informed by the plaintiffs’ counsel, Datuk Mohd Hafarizam Harun, that his clients had decided to withdraw the entire suit, including the application under the Federal Court’s original jurisdiction.Hafarizam said the decision was made in view of recent developments concerning the resignation of Menteri Besar Datuk Ismail Lasim, taking into account the constitutional provision that the entire state Exco would also cease to hold office when a Menteri Besar resigns.
“The reason for the withdrawal is that things have been overtaken by events, and that the Exco, in line with the constitutional provision that when a Menteri Besar resigns, the entire Exco will also fall or dissolve,” he said during the proceedings here today.However, Roz Mawar pointed out that Ismail had not formally resigned at the time of the hearing, noting that he had only tendered his resignation letter and that approval from the Yang Dipertuan Besar Negeri Sembilan Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir had yet to be received.Hafarizam replied that the plaintiffs had initially sought an adjournment until Friday to allow time for Tuanku Muhriz to issue a decree on the resignation, but after consulting their clients, they decided to withdraw the proceedings.The court also ordered the plaintiffs to pay costs of RM20,000 to the first defendant, the State Secretary; RM20,000 to the second defendant, the State Government; and RM8,000 to the third defendant, the Dewan Keadilan dan Undang Negeri Sembilan (DKU), subject to allocator.In her remarks, Roz Mawar said the court would not discourage any litigant from withdrawing legal proceedings, adding that it could be the more prudent course of action.However, she noted that the court had devoted considerable time and resources to the case since the originating summons was filed five months ago under a certificate of urgency, including dealing with various applications and setting timelines for the hearing of preliminary objections.
She said parties invoking the court’s jurisdiction, particularly on an urgent basis involving constitutional questions concerning the state government, also bore a responsibility towards the use of judicial resources, which were held in trust for the public.Earlier, Hafarizam also informed the court that the withdrawal was made without liberty to file afresh, including by way of judicial review.Counsel for the first defendant Datuk Dr Cyrus Das and counsel for the second defendant Razlan Hadri Zulkifli confirmed their consent to the withdrawal on the agreed terms, while counsel for the third defendant Steven Thiru also adopted the same position.
The 10 former Exco members had filed the lawsuit seeking an interpretation of the State Constitution and named the State Secretary and the State Government as defendants, while DKU was granted leave to intervene in the suit.The plaintiffs were also represented by counsels Tan Sri Azhar Azizan Harun, Datuk Syed Faisal Al-Edros Syed Abdullah, Norhazira Abu Haiyan and Muhammad Luqman Hakeem Abas, while the first defendant was also represented by Abdul Rashid Ismail, Siti Nurani Md Zahidi and Diong Pei Jing.Counsels Razlan Hadri Zulkifli, Marisa Regina Mohd Aris Rizal and Muhammad Yazid Mohamad Salim acted for the state government, while DKU was represented by Steven Thiru, David Mathew, Shafrin Halim and Gurjeevan Singh.

